The Sermon Study Guide is here.
John 15:1-8; Isaiah 5:1-7
March 22, 2015 • Portage First UMC
I’ve never been much of a gardener. My dad is good at it; he always had a big garden when I was growing up, and we spent many hours in late summer on the back patio snapping green beans and helping with other gardening chores. But I did not inherit his green thumb, though at two of the three parsonages we’ve lived in, I’ve tried my hand at it. In both Muncie and here, the parsonage had a garden space, and I feel guilty if I don’t plant something in that space. So I’ve tried a lot of different vegetables in the sandy ground that surrounds our home here. I even tried corn once; that didn’t work well. Peppers wouldn’t grow, at least under my guiding hand. Cucumbers did all right, as did green beans when I could keep the rabbits from eating them. About the only thing I’ve been consistently successful at growing is tomatoes—which, of course, is God’s little joke on me because I don’t eat tomatoes. But Cathy loves them, and most summers she’s had plenty to enjoy.
And then there is our grapevine. Ten years ago, when we arrived in Portage, Pastor Mary had planted a grapevine along the fence and she told me in another couple of years it would be producing grapes. So I watched it grow and, periodically, I’ve given you updates, especially the time when I got so excited at seeing little, tiny round grape-like things starting to grow. I began to have visions of using the grapes to make jellies and jams and maybe even juice for communion here at church. And I watched and I waited, and nothing ever came of it. No grapes grew. So about four years ago, I tore out the vine. Pulled every single vine out of the fence and cut it down to the ground. If it wasn’t going to produce, I wasn’t going to have it taking up space and making a mess. Vines are sneaky. I learned that because when I left for the Holy Land in 2012, the vine began to grow back. We were gone just a little over two weeks, in those two weeks, that vine grew back stronger than it had ever been. It taunts me as it grows along the fence, promising much but never producing. And when I look at it these days, I can’t help but think of Jesus’ claim to be “the vine.”
This morning, we’re continuing our Lenten journey through the “I am” statements of Jesus found throughout the Gospel of John as we seek to encounter “The God We Can Know.” So far, we’ve looked at Jesus’ claim to be the bread of life, the light of the world and the good shepherd. This morning, we’re going to jump ahead just a bit chronologically as we look at the last of the “I am” statements John reports Jesus saying: “I am the vine” (Card, John: The Gospel of Wisdom, pg. 167). In the next couple of weeks, up through Easter, we’ll come back and pick up the other ones; we’re saving those sayings because they take on special significance as we get closer to the cross and the empty tomb. But today, we want to join Jesus on the final walk he took with his disciples, where he shared one last image with them, one final illustration to help them understand what their life with him was going to look like from this moment on. Unlike the other sayings, this one was just for the disciples, so as we explore its meaning today, we’ll ask the questions we’ve been asking all along: what did the disciples hear when Jesus said this? What did he mean? And what does it mean for us today?
So in John 15, we are past the Last Supper and the washing of the disciples’ feet. At the end of chapter 14, Jesus’ last words are, “Come now, let us leave,” and so the next three chapters take place during their walk from the Upper Room, at one end of the Kidron Valley, to Gethsemane, at the other end of the valley. That would have been a twenty to twenty-five minute walk, and even today, it’s not an easy walk. On one of our trips to Jerusalem, we asked our guide if some of us could walk it, and he told us no. It wasn’t safe, and it wasn’t easy—then or now. On that last night Jesus had with his disciples, they would have left the upper room perhaps sometime after 11:00 p.m., which means it would be rather dark save for the full moon that is present at Passover time (cf. Hamilton, Journey to the Cross, pg. 40; 24 Hours That Changed the World, pg. 31). During this walk, Jesus knows he only has a short time to communicate some intimate, personal things to these men he loved so much, the ones who would carry on his mission, and so he uses this walk to do just that. The whole narrative reads rather disjointedly, which you would expect from a walk conversation, especially one in which Jesus is trying to share so much in a short time. But as they left the upper city, where the Passover feast took place, they head east and then north toward a grove of olive trees where they often went for prayer. Shortly after leaving the Upper Room, they would have passed by the south entrance of the Temple, over which was a huge sculpted vine, an ancient symbol of Israel. It’s very likely that, as they stood near or passed by that symbol, Jesus said to his followers, “I am the true vine, and my Father is the gardener…I am the vine; you are the branches” (15:1, 5; Card 167; Hamilton 24 33; Tenney, “The Gospel of John,” Expositor’s Bible Commentary, Vol. 9, pg. 150).
Viticulture (I learned a new word this week), or the practice of tending vineyards, was a common occupation in Israel during this time. The disciples would certainly have been familiar with the ways vines were tended, cultivated, harvested and how the fruit was turned into wine (Tenney 150). Still today in parts of Israel and Palestine, you can see where the land has been terraced so as to turn a hilly property into a series of flat spaces, like stair steps up the side of a hill. That way, vines can be grown and wine can be made (Wight, Manners and Customs of Bible Land, pg. 188). In fact, grapes and winemaking were a huge part of the first century economy, alongside olives and livestock (NIDOTB, Vol. 1, pgs. 74-79). So maybe out of all of Jesus’ statements, this one brings the most vivid images to the disciples’ minds. They knew what a vine, a grapevine, looked like.
More than that, the vine had been a symbol of Israel for a long time, as indicated by the huge stone vine on the side of the Temple entrance. Some even call the vine a “national symbol” of Israel, sort of like how the eagle is a national symbol of America (cf. Fuquay, The God We Can Know, pg. 73). And there was and is precedent for that all through the Old Testament. In Psalm 80, Asaph the psalmist remembers Israel’s history in terms of being a vine, brought out of Egypt: “You transplanted a vine from Egypt,” he sings, “you drove out the nations and planted it. You cleared the ground for it, and it took root and filled the land” (80:8-9). Isaiah is even more clear. He writes this: “My loved one had a vineyard on a fertile hillside. He dug it up and cleared it of stones and planted it with the choicest vines” (5:1-2). A few verses down from that, he says this: “The vineyard of the Lord Almighty is the nation of Israel, and the people of Judah are the vines he delighted in” (5:7). But, lest they begin to take pride in being God’s vine, it’s also clear in Isaiah that the nation has not produced what God expected them to produce. Isaiah 5:2 says, “Then he looked for a crop of good grapes, but it yielded only bad fruit.” And then, Isaiah goes on to say, “Now I will tell you what I am going to do to my vineyard: I will take away its hedge, and it will be destroyed; I will break down its wall, and it will be trampled. I will make it a wasteland, neither pruned nor cultivated, and briers and thorns will grow there” (5:5-6). The vine was the symbol of Israel, but the fruit it produced was bad. Isaiah told the people they were not the people God had hoped they would become. That imagery was surely in the minds of those who passed by the giant stone vine on the Temple, not the least of which were those disciples on that dark, moonlit night as they headed toward Gethsemane (cf. Tenney 150).
There are two huge images, then, that Jesus is trying to communicate here as he walks with his friends, two words we would do well to remember. Those words are “cut” and “prune.” Jesus puts it this way: “He [God the Father, the Gardener] cuts off every branch in me that bears no fruit, while every branch that does bear fruit he prunes so that it will be even more fruitful” (15:2). Those sound like the same thing in a way, but cutting off and pruning are two different actions; they have different ends. One of the tasks of a gardener is to monitor the vine, to keep a watch on it so that he, the gardener, knows exactly how it’s growing. That probably explains my epic failure as a vine grower, since I would only look at the vine once every two or three or more weeks. A good gardener, a true gardener, one whose livelihood depends on the health of the vine, keeps constant watch over the vine. You see, a vine left untended will put all of its energy into growing more and more and more vine. And the more vine grows, the more tangled the plant becomes. Eventually, the vines on the top will be stealing all the sunlight, and without light, the branches that are at the bottom will wither and die (Wright, John for Everyone, Part Two, pg. 69). Dead branches, of course, no longer take sap or energy from the vine, but it does take strength and energy for the vine to hold up the dead branches (Fuquay 79). Holding onto dead weight takes a lot of effort. Beyond that, the dead branches are of no use to the vine or to anyone.
So, a good gardener comes along and cuts off the dead branches. They are gathered and burned, because dead grape branches were of no use to anyone in the first century. In order for the vine as a whole to be healthy, sometimes the dead parts or the parts that are sucking the life out of the vine need to be cut off and forgotten. Now, think with me about how that applies to followers of Jesus. Jesus is the vine, he says, and we are the branches. He is the main plant; he is the one who is giving life and health and strength out to the branches, sustaining the branches. Without him, we have no life. But there are branches that sometimes need to be cut off. Let me put it as plainly as I can: that can be true of our individual lives and it can be true of our church life. If the church is the Body of Christ, if we are branches on the vine, then there can be, Jesus says, dead branches, life-sucking branches that the Father will cut off. Sometimes in your life or in the life of an organization like the church, those dead branches come in the form of people who take and take and take and demand attention and rarely see beyond their own lives. And it’s easy for us to get sucked into their lives. One of the things we talked about when we did Stephen Ministry training is that we must not give in to feeling guilty when we find we have to walk away from certain situations. Sometimes, it’s simply not healthy to stay connected because it’s easier for them to pull us away from the life-giving vine than it is for us to pull them back to the vine. Every branch that does not bear fruit, that does not give life, is cut away.
Sometimes the dead branches that need to be cut off are things we’re holding onto in our past—things like regrets and resentments, anger and bitterness, envy and just generally living in the past and rehearsing old hurts. Those can become dead branches that weigh us down and take us away from the best God has for us. Have you known someone who is continually focused on their anger or their bitterness or what someone supposedly did to them years ago? It’s hard if not impossible for those folks to enjoy the life and the abundance that Jesus the vine offers if they are insistent on harboring dead branches. The question we have to ask of each branch, of each part of our lives, according to Jesus, is whether or not fruit is evident. Every dead branch must be cut away for us to find the life that really is life.
Then Jesus says there’s this other practice that happens in viticulture (if I learned the word, I’m going to use it!); that practice is pruning. The word he uses here is very close to the word used for “clean” in verse 3, where Jesus tells these disciples, “You are already clean [or pure] because of the word I have spoken to you” (15:3). Jesus is drawing a connection between being pruned and being clean or pure (Wright 70). But what does it mean to “prune” the vine? Pruning takes place not on the dead wood; pruning takes place on the branches that are, in fact, already producing fruit. Good, healthy branches need pruning or else they will spend their energy producing more branches rather than doing what they were meant to do, to create grapes, better fruit. It’s a trimming process, and for the follower of Jesus it means that we submit to having other goals and ambitions cut away. It’s a process of having our focus put on being fruitful for the gardener, for our Master. Such a process led Paul to declare, “I want to know Christ—yes, to know the power of his resurrection and participation in his sufferings, becoming like him in his death” (Philippians 3:10). Paul had all sorts of ambitions and goals when he was a young man, but it took Jesus knocking him off a horse, removing his eyesight for three days and exposing him to the power of the message about the cross for Paul to become focused on one clear goal: to know Christ and, thereby, to preach Christ. That’s some pretty serious pruning! It was pruning that caused philosopher Soren Kierkegaard to declare that purity of heart is to will one thing. One thing! That’s what Jesus is getting at here. When he says the disciples are “clean” or “pure,” he’s focusing them. Lots of things were going to happen in the next few hours, but they needed to stay focused on one thing, on the most important thing. They had been pruned; their old ambitions and goals had been stripped away until they were focused on Jesus. In the next few hours, they would face more pruning yet, and in the end, they would emerge as people focused on one goal: to tell the story of Jesus. Pruning is whatever comes to us that helps us focus on and realize what is most important (cf. Tenney 151).
Rachel was not very old, somewhere around a year, when we discovered that there was a problem with her kidneys. Her pediatrician had blown it off, accused me of worrying too much, so we took her to another doctor who found the problem. Hopefully, we were told, she would grow out of it. Her cousin, my brother’s daughter, who had the exact same issue, did grow out of it, but as each year passed, it became apparent Rachel would not. Every year we would take her down to Riley Hospital in Indianapolis, and every year, as we prepared for the trip down there and as we traveled, I would have this “poor me” feeling creep into my heart, life and attitude. On one of the years where it was getting closer to her needing surgery, I was feeling especially sorry for myself—not for Rachel, for myself—and we found that we had some extra time between appointments, so we wandered over to the McDonald’s that is in the lobby of Riley Hospital. As we walked, we saw so many kids who were going through so many different sorts of struggles, and suddenly the Master Gardener began to work on my branch. God began to whisper to my heart, “Do you see these families? They are going through much worse than you are. Perhaps you should stop focusing on yourself and be a light shining in the midst of so much darkness that is here.” Snip, snip—pruning taking place. As I listened to the Spirit of God speaking to my spirit, I began to realize that, though Rachel’s illness was not something God caused or something we wanted, God could use it and use us in the time we were there. That wasn’t the first time or the last time that God pruned my heart, that God called me beyond myself to see possibilities, even in the difficult places, for me to bear fruit. If we’re listening, we can hear his voice in our hearts probably every day as he prunes us, shapes us, and makes us able to bear even more and better fruit, to focus on what is most important.
But do you know something I have discovered each and every time I’ve gone through pruning? It’s in those times, when I open my life to the pruning shears of the great Gardener, that I grow the most in my faith journey. And that makes sense, because it’s also at that time when the Gardener is closest to us. That’s true in pruning grape vines; the gardener is never closer physically to the vine, nor is he ever more concerned about the health and well-being of the vine, than he is when he is going through the process of pruning (cf. Wright 71). Though pruning in our lives may be difficult and it may hurt, God is with us every step of the way. He is closest to us during our most difficult times.
So, what does all of this mean for us? What does this “I am” statement have to say about our place in the world, our purpose in life? Jesus says the purpose of the branches is to bear “much fruit,” and by such fruit we will show ourselves to be his disciples (15:8). A bit earlier in the evening, Jesus had told these same men that the way the world would know they were his disciples is if they love one another (13:35). “A new command I give you,” he said as they sat at the table. “Love one another. As I have loved you, so you must love one another” (13:34), and then just a bit later, he told them, “If you love me, keep my commands” (14:15). So the fruit we are to bear, the life we are to live is connected to love—and not the mushy, Hallmark kind of love. This is agape—self-sacrificial love. The kind of love God has for us. The kind of love that is willing to lay down its life for the other person. He prunes us so that we can love more, so that we can bear much fruit. If we’re not growing in love, if we don’t love others more now than we did, say, a year ago, we have to question if we’re really allowing God to work in us, to prune us. We have to wonder if we might be in danger of being dead wood that is cut out.
Paul picked up on this same theme in his letter to the Galatians, where he talks about what the evidence is of Christ working in us. He says anyone can see the evidence that God is not working in us—things like rage, selfish ambition, hatred, discord, envy and even worse things show up in our lives (Galatians 5:19-21). Those things, Paul seems to say, are easy. Anyone can do them. They are our “natural” state. But there is another way to live, Paul says, another character we can allow to grow in us. He calls it, in the tradition of Jesus, the “fruit of the spirit.” Maybe you remember the list: “The fruit of the spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance [or patience], kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control” (5:22-23). I don’t think Paul just happened to put “love” at the top of the list because it seems that all the rest of the fruit flow out of love. Without love, the rest of the fruit are impossible. Elsewhere, of course, Paul tells us that the greatest of all characteristics is love (cf. 1 Corinthians 13:3) because it is the most Christ-like. As we become more loving we become more like Jesus, the one who forgave even the people who were nailing him to the cross. God the Gardener prunes us so that we will become more like his son, but to be able to do that fully we have to stay connected to Jesus. He says we are the branches, he is the vine, and if a branch isn’t connected to the vine, it’s useless and soon dead.
So how do we stay connected to Jesus? First of all, we have to stay in the word. Jesus says pruning takes place through the word that is spoken to the disciples (15:3). For those of us who live two thousand years after Jesus walked the earth, pruning takes place through the word that has been preserved for us in the Scriptures. It’s absolutely essential to us as followers of Jesus to stay connected to him through studying the Scriptures and listening to the ways he speaks to us through this word. So that includes personal study of the Scriptures, setting aside some time each day to read and allow the words of the Bible to point you toward the Word of God, Jesus. I’m not saying it’s easy to find that time; you have to set it aside or it will never happen. For me, as I’ve shared before, that’s the first thing I do every morning. I have a place in our home where I go each morning after waking Rachel up for school and that’s my reading and prayer place. If I don’t keep that appointment every morning, my whole day is off and I feel disconnected. I need that time to hear from God. Some mornings the Scripture jumps off the page at me and sometimes I may not “hear” anything through my reading. That’s okay, because I know God is using that word to shape and prune me even when I don’t know it or realize it. And I find that, as I read the Scriptures over and over year by year, God speaks to me in new and sometimes surprising ways even though I’ve read that psalm or that parable before.
And while personal study is vital, so is coming together with the body of Christ to read and study. For ten years now, I’ve shared over and over again my desire and goal that each and every person who is connected with Portage First be a part of a small group that connects to the Scriptures and connects to each other. We’ve made some progress, but there is still a long way to go. Are you involved in a small group, whether it’s one we “officially” sponsor or not? Are you connected to a group that helps you connect to the savior? It might be a Sunday School class or a FISH group or some other small group. But being part of a community, a group that helps us grow, is essential to staying connected to the vine—at least in part because it’s only in community that we can really learn to love others, even those who irritate us, whom we don’t like, or who aren’t like us. Love grows, sometimes with difficulty but it grows nonetheless, in community.
There are other practices, disciplines that help us remain in Jesus as well, and we talk about many of them often. Prayer is the ongoing conversation we have with our Gardener, as he often directs our growth and shows us areas where we most need pruning. Baptism and communion are physical acts that demonstrate our desired connection with Jesus. In some respects, they are acts that announce our “branch” status, our connection to the vine and our desire to bear fruit. John Wesley listed several other practices, which he called “means of grace,” that can help us become and stay connected to the vine, things such as fasting (going without something for a time so that we can spend that time connecting with Jesus), attending worship, healthy living, sharing our faith with others, and Christian conferencing (or seeking the input of others in our decisions). All of those are good and helpful and important, but I want to suggest one more that I hadn’t thought of until I had a conversation with another pastor this week. We were talking about the Lenten season and things that help us grow, and he mentioned how he finds it helpful to read biographies of great Christian saints—and not necessarily “saints” in the traditional, canonized sense, but people who have served God faithfully and well. As we talked, I realized that I have often found myself encouraged in my faith and better challenged to live a life of love when I read a story or a book like that. There’s something about hearing someone else’s story and the way Jesus has worked in their lives that spurs us on and calls us to greater faithfulness. Perhaps that’s a practice that would help you this Lenten season, not replacing Scripture reading but in addition to it. Scripture is always primary, and then God gives us other opportunities to grow the fruit that he longs to see in us.
And one more thing: everything we do is done for God’s glory and not our own. We most often give lip service to wanting God to receive the glory. We sing about it here at church, we may even talk about it in small groups, but then we spend most of the week trying to get glory and notice and recognition for ourselves. Jesus reminds us that we are branches, connected to the vine, and any fruit we grow, any results we bear are only due to what we receive from the vine—from him. He gives us life. He gives us strength. He gives us whatever abilities we have. He helps us love those who are difficult to love. And he prunes us to make us better, stronger, more loving. For all of those reasons, we are called to give God the glory, to pray along with the psalmist, “Not to us, Lord, not to us but to your name be the glory, because of your love and faithfulness” (Psalm 115:1). We live for the sake of God’s glory.
Jesus said, “I am the vine; you are the branches…apart from me you can do nothing.” But with him and in him, all things are possible…even loving one another. Thanks be to God. Let’s pray.