The Sermon Study Guide is here.
Psalm 139:13-14; 1 Samuel 16:1-13
September 29, 2013 • Portage First UMC
VIDEO INTRO
Michelle was eight years old when she first began to believe she was fat. She was sitting between two friends at a school assembly and noticed that her legs were bigger than both of her friends’ legs. From that moment on, she kept hiding her legs, hoping no one would notice, and she struggled with her body image, constantly worried about what others thought of the way she looked. When she was a freshmen in college, she contracted mononucleosis, which killed her appetite and made her tired most of the time. During the six weeks she battled the disease, she barely ate anything. She knew she was losing weight, but she had no idea how much until she went to the doctor’s office, where the nurse gasped as she weighed Michelle. She had lost twenty pounds in six weeks. That gave Michelle an idea. If she could lose 3.5 pounds a week without working out, how much could she lose if she started working out again? So she did. She aimed toward “the perfect weight,” which she never really defined, except that it was something less than her current weight of 118 pounds. Six weeks after that doctor’s visit, she was down to 105 pounds.
And how did people react? Everyone complimented her. People at church would ask, “What’s your secret?” Girls would give her jealous stares when she passed them on the street, and guys started paying more attention to her than they ever had. She loved the attention, and yet at just over 100 pounds, she still felt fat. She started eating smaller meals, skipping some meals, and taking appetite suppressants and fat burning medicines. Then she began competing in beauty pageants, and despite people fussing over how thin she was, all she could see when she looked in the mirror was a chunky stomach. At this point, she was down to 89 pounds. She would go to church, hold the communion bread in her mouth and then sneak out to spit it out into the toilet. She put it this way: “I couldn’t even bring myself to sacrifice ten calories to remember the fact that [Jesus] suffered a horrible death and sacrificed himself so I could spend eternity with him.”
She began training for a marathon, and in the first part of April 2005, she went thirteen straight days without eating a single meal. During a run that was part of her training, her vision suddenly began to blur. She tripped and fell to the ground. All 84 pounds of her hit the pavement and it felt, she said, like every brittle bone in her body cracked all at once. She could no longer deny it, nor could she hide it from others. She had a problem. She was worshipping at the altar of beauty, the altar of appearance—an altar that, like the money we talked about last week, is set up in every corner of our culture today. Michelle knew couldn’t get out of that lifestyle without serious help from her friends, her family and God (cf. Wilson, Empty Promises, pgs. 133-136).
Unfortunately, Michelle’s story is not an unusual one. Four out of ten individuals in our country have either personally experienced an eating disorder or know someone who has. It’s estimated that ten million women face a daily struggle with an eating disorder, but what has typically been thought of as a woman’s issue is now a growing concern for men as well. Today, somewhere around one million men struggle with this issue—a number that is growing. The numbers are even higher for those in organized sports: 42% of female athletes demonstrate behaviors that are connected with eating disorders. They may not be there yet, but without intervention many if not most of them will develop a full-blown problem with food. Even if we’re not struggling with an eating disorder, many of us are still aiming at a better body image, a more perfect sense of self. That’s evidenced by the fact that on any given day, 25% of American men and 45% of American women report being on a diet. Even more staggering is the fact that 46% of 9-11 year olds report being “very often on a diet.” Now, some dieting is good. Most all of us get told by our doctors we could stand to lose a few pounds. It’s when we become focused on a particular body image, a way of appearing or a certain type of beauty, that we stray into the area of idolatry. It’s easy to find ourselves worshipping at the altar of beauty and appearance.
This morning, we’re continuing our series on “Empty Promises,” exploring those things that attempt to take God’s place in our lives. We call them “idols,” which for many of us probably bring up images in our minds of little carved statues. But today’s idols are much more subtle and yet more overt than those ancient statues would have been. For instance, so far, we’ve talked about things like achievement, affirmation and money as idols, and we’ve looked at the promises such things make to bring us fulfillment, attention, or meaning in our lives. But those things never can fulfill those promises. They can never quite live up to the supposed potential. Only God can, and yet for many of us, these things take the place of God in our lives. We might not say that they are more important, but we demonstrate it with our lives. We show what is important with the amount of time and resources we dedicate to them. The same is true of beauty or appearance. In today’s world, beauty has become a highly valued quality—or, we could even say, commodity, because beauty is used to market everything. Products are sold by young, beautiful and seemingly happy people. They are sold using a generous amount of sexuality, a quality which usually has nothing to do with the product being sold. Does that hair shampoo really make you sexy? Will buying that brand of fruit juice make you more desirable? That’s what the advertisers would have you believe. Children are made fun of at school if they don’t have the “right” brand names on their clothing. And political campaigns seek to polish a successful media image rather than to convince you of their stance on the issues (Birch, “The First and Second Books of Samuel,” New Interpreter’s Bible, Vol. II, pg. 1100). Those who study such things point to the election of 1960 as the turning point, because that was the first “mass media election.” John F. Kennedy and Richard Nixon both appeared on television, debating in that sort of forum for the first time. Kennedy was tanned and photogenic. Nixon looked pale and had a noticeable 5 o’clock shadow. Voters took more quickly to Kennedy because his campaign understood the power of the media and knew how to use it. That’s continued up to today, only now it’s less about debates and more about who shows up on late night talk shows and on Twitter. Image matters. Appearance is critical. Pick up any magazine, watch any commercial, visit almost any website and you’ll hear the same message: beauty is in. Our culture worships at its altar. And, we’re told, if you worship at it, too, people will love you. They will listen to you. They will admire and even desire you. It’s a tempting idol, which is why it has taken over so much of our culture.
But it’s nothing new. Even in ancient times, beauty or appearance was highly desirable. Granted, the appearance they looked for was not what we look for. In fact, in many ancient cultures, people who were overweight were considered the most beautiful, and do you know why? Because they were obviously wealthy and had leisure time to be able to eat and eat well! They didn’t have to work—so we even get a connection even in ancient times (and still today) between the idol of beauty and the idol of money. But, regardless of the particulars, appearance was important, especially when it came to choosing a leader, a king, so let’s look at a story from the Old Testament, from 1 Samuel, and see how this played out in the life of two men who would be king: Saul and David.
Saul was the first king of Israel, chosen after the people basically rejected God as their king because they wanted to be like everyone else (1 Samuel 8:4-9). And so, Saul was chosen, and from all accounts, he was exactly what people wanted in a king—or at least in the appearance of a king. He was “as handsome a young man as could be found anywhere in Israel, and he was a head taller than anyone else” (1 Samuel 9:2). He was impressive to look at, but he had serious character flaws which become apparent not long after he is chosen and anointed as king. In fact, after Saul blatantly disobeys God’s command after a battle, God rejects Saul as king and sets out to look for another candidate.
That’s where we come into the story today as we read from 1 Samuel 16. Samuel, the prophet, is upset. He’s discouraged because things have gone so badly with Saul, and the future looks rather bleak for the nation. But God tells Samuel to stop brooding and go anoint a new king. “I am sending you to Jesse of Bethlehem,” God says. “I have chosen one of his sons to be king” (16:1). Now, wouldn’t it have been easier if God had just told Samuel straight out which son he had chosen? Jesse has eight sons. Couldn’t God had given Samuel some sort of clue? Apparently not, as this whole exercise is presented as a matter of “seeing.” Where our translations read “chosen,” God literally says, “I have seen for myself a king.” I’ve picked him out. I’ve noticed him. So it becomes a matter of trust for Samuel, and a chance for him to see people the way God sees them (Birch 1097).
Samuel, however, is nervous. He knows if he goes to anoint a new king while the old king is still alive, he could lose his life. It would be treason to do such a thing (Birch 1098)! So God tells him to tell everyone he’s come to make a sacrifice. Now, some accuse God of lying here, but actually wherever the prophet went, sacrifices were usually offered. So Samuel is not told to lie so much as withhold the whole truth. Only tell part of it until you get there. So he goes to Bethlehem (a town, by the way, of little importance in those days, a nothing town), and when he arrives, the people are afraid. The arrival of a prophet is usually bad news (Goldingay, 1 & 2 Samuel for Everyone, pg. 79)! “Do you come in peace?” they ask (16:4), and Samuel assures them that he does. Then he invites the people to come with him to Jesse’s house, and there he finds seven sons. The oldest is named Eliab, and he is tall and strong and good looking. Samuel notices him right away and thinks he must be the one God has chosen. Obviously, he’s the oldest, and he has the “look” of a king. Samuel “saw” Eliab, the text says, but he didn’t really “see” him. God responds immediately with a rebuke: “Do not consider his appearance or his height, for I have rejected him. The Lord does not look at the things people look at. People look at the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart” (16:7). Samuel gets a quick lesson in seeing the world the way God sees it. He was “looking” but not “seeing” (Birch 1098). Outward appearance matters little. What matters is the state and the “appearance” of the heart.
This same sort of event happens with all seven of the sons who are there. Apparently, it takes that many times for Samuel to be able to both hear the voice of God and to be able to see people the way God sees them. But when the seven have passed and there is still no king, Samuel begins to wonder. “Are these all the sons you have?” (16:11). You can almost hear the reluctance in Jesse’s voice, almost as if he’s saying, “These are the only ones that count.” Well, he says, there’s one more son. He’s not much. In fact, since he’s the youngest, he’s out tending the sheep. He’ll never be more than a shepherd boy, so I didn’t bother calling him in. This boy is the youngest in a family that didn’t have much of a reputation anyway. His great-grandmother was a Moabite, a foreigner, named Ruth. His great-grandfather, Boaz, had an ancestor, Tamar, who was famously almost executed for adultery. This family is not the stuff of royalty, and being the youngest of the family, this boy basically had no hope. He wouldn’t ever be much more than a shepherd (cf. Birch 1100). But Samuel is determined, so he asks for them to send for the youngest. Go get him. We won’t sit down until he gets back here. Now, shepherds could sometimes be quite a distance away from home. I wonder what they talked about in the time it took for someone to go get the boy. “So, how’s the weather been?” “Well, you know, dry and dusty.” Long silence. “So, not much rain?” “Nope.” I mean, imagine the uncomfortable silence, the wondering, on this day that had started with anticipation and excitement and has turned to a long period of waiting while “the boy” comes in.
Eventually, he arrives, and God says, “This is the one. Anoint him” (16:12). Now, the author does tell us that this boy was “glowing with health” and was handsome as well. But that’s not why God chooses him. He’s the last person most people would have chosen, and while his kingship will reveal that he has character flaws at least as great as Saul’s, this boy has a different heart. It’s the heart that matters. God looks on the heart, we are told. The heart has to do with the will and the character of a person, and David’s heart was unwaveringly focused on God (Birch 1099; Goldingay 79). David is the man after God’s own heart, and as future events will show, even when he messes up and when he sins, he turns immediately back to God. He doesn’t try to justify himself; he simply repents. That’s his heart, and that’s what makes the difference. It’s what’s under the surface—it’s David’s heart—that makes him the object of God’s attention and eventually will turn him into the greatest king Israel ever knew.
What made the difference between the hearts of David and his brothers? Could it have anything to do with all the time he spent by himself out in the wilderness with the sheep? There, he had learned to rely on God’s protection, provision and approval above everything else. It seems he used the time in the wilderness, in the quiet and desolation of the desert, to develop his spiritual life. His heart beat with God’s heart, and that made him, imperfect though he may have been, the perfect king for Israel. Not his appearance. Not his stature. Not even his great gifts in administration. It was his heart that made the difference. If only we would learn to put that sort of stock into people’s hearts today. If only we would seek to see people the way God sees them. If only we would invest the sort of energy into our spiritual lives that we do into being noticed, into worshipping at the altar of appearance. Rather than listening to the still, small voice of the Spirit of God, many of us continue to listen to two primary lies our culture tells us. First, “being beautiful will get me what I want” (Wilson 129). In the short term, that promise is true. In the short term. We’ve all seen instances where appearance mattered, where it made a difference in who got the job or the attention. We even obediently tune into the various awards shows on television and watch as the beautiful people parade around in ridiculously expensive clothes and hosts comment on how they look. But that lie is only true in the short term. Beauty fades. Appearance changes. Diet and exercise and hair coloring and plastic surgery can only delay the inevitable for a time. If only for purely physical reasons, the idol of appearance lets everyone down in the end.
Believing this lie can even be destructive. Just think about the story we began with this morning, the story of Michelle. Her pursuit of a certain look (undefined, but a sense that she’d know it when she arrived at it) nearly killed her, as it has so many people, so many “beautiful” people. Or what about the story that was in the news not that long ago about the mother from San Francisco who injected her eight-year-old daughter with Botox to minimize her “wrinkles”? The girl was competing in beauty pageants—at eight years old—and when people were upset, the mother’s response was that “everyone’s doing it” (Wilson 136). We increasingly live in a world where people will do most anything and sacrifice even their children in order to appear a certain way, to get what they want. All that matters is what’s on the surface.
And that leads us to a second lie, one that probably more of us believe, whether we admit it or not: how I look is who I am. We learn this early on in life. I’ve shared the story before about a friend of mine who used to sing in a youth choir, and when she would sing, she would just smile from ear to ear. One day, after they sang, she asked her father, who is not a cruel man, how they did, and he said, “You know, you shouldn’t smile so much up there. You need to focus more on your singing.” And you know what? She stopped smiling—not only in choir. That single comment impacted her more, I’m sure, than her father intended. She heard that she wasn’t valuable because of the way she looked in that moment. Pastor Pete Wilson tells about John, a successful businessman, who one night at dinner with his grown daughters and their families was sharing about the weight he had recently lost by counting calories when suddenly his oldest daughter broke down in tears. Once he got her calmed down, he asked what was wrong. “Dad,” she said, “one day when I was twelve years old, you told me that I was looking a little chubby. Your remark has haunted me for the past twenty-two years. Hardly a day has gone by, and certainly never a week, that I don’t think about those words you spoke to me. I know you weren’t trying to hurt me, but it’s had a huge negative impact on my life” (Wilson 137). I’ve heard from many others who have heard a comment from a parent or a person in authority every day in their life. “You look good that way,” or, more often, “You need to...lose weight...not wear that...do this or that…” And those comments stick. Remember what I said a couple of weeks about affirmation and approval? We hang onto negative comments much more easily than we do positive ones. And children especially do that, to the point that it’s easy to believe how we look is who we are.
So we post pictures on Facebook or we show photos in our wallets. And what are the comments we get? “You’re beautiful.” “They’re so cute.” “They’ve gotten so big.” We focus on the appearance, and we neglect matters of the heart. But God is focused on the heart, on what kind of person we’re becoming, what character is developing within us. And God, who created us, loves us just because we are. The psalmist praised God for that fact: “You [God] created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are wonderful, I know that full well” (Psalm 139:13-14). If God’s works are wonderful, and we are God’s work, then we are wonderful. It’s that simple. Doesn’t matter what we look like. Neil Anderson says, “Most people spend a lifetime trying to become what they already are.” Here’s the reality: you are already loved. You are already accepted. You are already valued. You are already lovely. Your outward appearance will not heal your inner brokenness. Who you are is not how you look. You can’t control what others think about you with your outward appearance, no matter what you do. The call to us, instead, is to develop character that reflects the image of Christ to our world. What’s under the surface is what will last and what ultimately matters.
Children and grandchildren especially need to hear that they are loved—not only by you, but by God as well. They need to know they are valuable in God’s sight, just because they are. And they need to know that they are worth more than just their appearance. There’s a marvelous scene in the film Mr. Holland’s Opus that shows what that can look like. Mr. Holland, a music teacher, has a son who is deaf, and he is initially angry that he can’t share his love of music with his son. While his wife learns sign language, Mr. Holland himself resists, which causes struggle and stress in the family. As his story progresses, though, Mr. Holland comes to a realization of what’s really important. Let’s watch.
The solution to the idol of appearance is to open our hearts and allow God to wash over us with his love. We have to embrace that truth with more than just our heads. God wants to transform our hearts. There are few things more beautiful than a person who is fully following Jesus, someone who accepts himself or herself as a person created and loved by God. That’s a person of true beauty.
There is a marvelous children’s story many of you know that really sums up the message this morning. It’s the story of a velveteen rabbit that was a gift on Christmas morning to a little boy. In fact, the rabbit was the best gift in the stocking that morning. But in the days that followed, he wasn’t always played with. There were so many presents, so many new toys, and the other toys in the nursery sometimes bragged about the attention they received. They made the rabbit feel insignificant and commonplace and ugly.
But also in the nursery was a Skin Horse, who had lived there longer than any other toy. And one day, the Rabbit turned to the Skin Horse for advice. Here’s how the story goes from there: “What is REAL?” asked the Rabbit one day, when they were lying side by side near the nursery fender, before Nana came to tidy the room. “Does it mean having things that buzz inside you and a stick-out handle?” “Real isn't how you are made,” said the Skin Horse. “It's a thing that happens to you. When a child loves you for a long, long time, not just to play with, but REALLY loves you, then you become Real.”
“Does it hurt?” asked the Rabbit. “Sometimes,” said the Skin Horse, for he was always truthful. “When you are Real you don't mind being hurt.” “Does it happen all at once, like being wound up,” he asked, “or bit by bit?” “It doesn’t happen all at once,” said the Skin Horse. “You become. It takes a long time. That’s why it doesn't happen often to people who break easily, or have sharp edges, or who have to be carefully kept. Generally, by the time you are Real, most of your hair has been loved off, and your eyes drop out and you get loose in the joints and very shabby. But these things don't matter at all, because once you are Real you can’t be ugly, except to people who don’t understand.”
“The Lord does not look at the things people look at. People look at the outward appearance, but the Lord looks at the heart” (16:7). Let’s pray.