The Sermon Study Guide is here.
John 18:28-40; Acts 4:8-13
January 20, 2013 • Portage First UMC
VIDEO INTRO
In the dim, dark hours of the morning, a man is led up the steps of the imposing Antonia Fortress. This huge building, backing up against the sacred areas of the city center, was a constant reminder to all who walked by of the power of Rome. Usually, it was simply occupied with a peacekeeping force, a group of soldiers who had little to do but play games and occasionally make a show of force. But this time of year, this time when the city population swelled, it was home to the governor, a man named Pontius Pilate. Pilate hated Jerusalem. He hated Judea. It was so far from the center of power, from Rome, and he had taken this job assuming it was a stepping stone to something greater. If he did well here, he thought, he might get a quieter province, better pay, better living conditions (cf. Wright, John for Everyone, Part Two, pg. 110). Most of the time, he was on the coast, at Caesarea, but when Passover came, he knew he had to be in Jerusalem. Those Jews were always causing trouble here, and especially during this festival that celebrated their freedom, a freedom they really hadn’t had in a long time. The Passover reminded them of that ancient day when Moses had led them out of slavery in Egypt. Now, they were little more than slaves to Rome, but when Passover came, there was always the danger that they would get this freedom bug in their minds and try something. So, reluctantly, Pilate came here for the celebration. And with every passing year, he hated it more.
Pilate always came to the Fortress early. Like most Roman rulers, he wanted to get the business of the day done before it got too hot, because then he could spend the rest of the day in the spa (Card, The Parable of Joy, pg. 214). This day, though, that was not to be, because sometime between 6:00 and 7:00 a.m., the rabble arrived. The religious leaders came with a man in chains. They looked like they had all been up all night. Of course, they wouldn’t come in to the Fortress; to do so wouldn’t allow them to eat the Passover. Pilate didn’t understand why; he didn’t really care why. It just meant more work for him, going back and forth as he interviewed the prisoner inside, then came outside to talk to them. “What charges are you bringing against this man?” he asked, already bored. He tried not to let it show, but he didn’t really care if they noticed or not. “If he were not a criminal,” they said, “we would not have handed him over to you.” Well, that wasn’t really an answer to the question, was it, now? Pilate was going to have to try to find out from the man himself what was going on. And so it went. All Pilate could sort of figure out was that this peasant, obviously a poor man from Galilee which was a poor part of the country, had claimed to be a king at some point. That was laughable! There was no way this man was going to be a king. And the other thing that was clear is that these religious leaders wanted Pilate to execute the prisoner. An execution. At Passover. That wouldn’t do well for his poll numbers except with these religious leaders.
So he interviewed Jesus, asked about this “king” thing, challenged him, and finally got Jesus to say, “The reason I was born and came into the world is to testify to the truth. Everyone on the side of truth listens to me” (18:37). That caused Pilate to stop the interview, and he only asks one more question, but it’s not directed at anyone in particular. How did he say it? Was he facetious, scornful, impatient, despairing, or sincere (Tenney, “The Gospel of John,” Expositor’s Bible Commentary, Vol. 9, pg. 176)? I’ve always heard the question being asked with an undertone of longing. The question is one people throughout the centuries have asked: “What is truth?” Pilate, like many people still today, asks the question, but he doesn’t stick around to hear an answer. He doesn’t realize that truth is, in fact, standing right in front of him.
Not too long after Pilate’s encounter with Jesus, but after Jesus’ death and resurrection, some of Jesus’ followers are brought in for questioning, to the same room where the religious leaders decided Jesus ought to die. Peter and John, both part of the original twelve disciples, are brought up on charges and dragged before the Sanhedrin, the Jewish ruling council. The charge? They’ve been preaching about Jesus out on the street corner, and more than that, they’ve been telling people that Jesus was raised from the dead, that Jesus had defeated death and that a new world was coming into being. Well, that bothers people who are in power in this world (cf. Wright, Acts for Everyone, Part One, pg. 63), so when they are put on trial of sorts, Peter, the fisherman from Galilee, finds the courage to speak to those who are the elite of society. To these who are the powerful, Peter speaks of the core of Christian belief: “Salvation is found in no one else, for there is no other name under heaven given to mankind by which we must be saved” (4:12). That name he’s referring to? The source of salvation? It’s the name of Jesus, the one they crucified, the one who was raised from the dead. He is the answer to Pilate’s question.
But not everyone shares that belief or embraces that truth. I think I was in college before I met a person I knew was genuinely from another faith. In our little town, most everyone I knew went to church. Or, at least, they belonged to a church somewhere. There were three churches in Rossville when I was a kid—the Methodist church, the Presbyterian church, and the Church of the Brethren. And it was still a cultural thing to show up. There weren’t practicing Hindus or Muslims or even Jews that I knew of. We were pretty much just standard Protestants, and it wasn’t until I went to Ball State that I began to encounter other beliefs, other faiths, even people who claimed no faith at all. Yet even then, as I recall, most groups pretty well kept to themselves. But no longer. The world has changed, even to the point where we seem to have lost the ability to have civil discourse and even disagreements without resorting to name-calling. Standing up for what we believe as Christians, holding onto that belief that Jesus is still the source of salvation, the only hope for this world, the truth, sometimes gets us in trouble today whereas it was assumed in the world I grew up in. Saying things like that might even get us labeled as “insensitive toward other faiths.” That’s by and large the popular perception that shows up in all sorts of conversations, movies, television shows and on the internet. Christians are considered to be narrow-minded, or insensitive, especially when it comes to people who believe differently than we do. But that, my friends, is a myth.
During these weeks, we’re looking at some popular “myths” about the Christian faith—things that are believed without any proof, things that people believe in part because there are folks who claim the name of Jesus and act like that. But the question we’re asking during this series is whether or not these statements, these beliefs, hold up to the standard of Scripture. In other words, this week we want to ask: is the Christian faith, at its heart, as Jesus intended, insensitive toward those who believe differently? Sometimes we take those Scripture passages we’re looking at this morning and use them to bully people. It is true, however, that since the beginning of the church, our belief has been that salvation comes through and because of the work of Jesus Christ, that in some mysterious way, his death on the cross has allowed us to find forgiveness from our sin, from the ways we have rebelled against God. We know of no other way for salvation to happen. We believe that Jesus is, as he said, the way, the truth and the life (cf. John 14:6). And we believe salvation is a gift, that Jesus did it for us, offers it to us, and that it’s available to everyone.
In addition, we are called to spread that good news about Jesus. That was the last thing he told us to do: “Go and make disciples of all nations…” (Matthew 28:19). In Acts, he tells the disciples, “You will be my witnesses…to the ends of the earth” (1:8). We are called to share our faith, to invite others to know Jesus, to find eternal life. But the question has to do with how we go about that. Peter, in one of his letters, called the church to share its faith at all times: “Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have.” But, he goes on: “Do this with gentleness and respect, keeping a clear conscience, so that those who speak maliciously against your good behavior in Christ may be ashamed of their slander” (1 Peter 3:15-16). Gentleness. Respect. While we may not and most likely will not agree with those who belong to other faiths, and while we may, in fact, want to share Jesus with them, we’re also called to be sensitive to their situation and their needs. The Christian faith, at its heart, is not meant to be insensitive to others. Those who act in insensitive ways are not practicing the faith Jesus calls us to.
So if we want to combat that myth, how should we respond to those who have a different faith? Because our world is not only increasingly multi-cultural, it’s also multi-religious. “Truth” has become relative. The Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life found in 2012 that 73% of the American population still claim to be Christian, though 49% of people say they “seldom or never” attend worship. The next largest religious body in America is Judaism, followed them by Islam and other so-called “eastern” religions. As was widely reported, though, the fastest growing group on America’s religious landscape are the “nones.” Almost 20% of people who were asked about their religious affiliation said they had “none.” So how do we respond to this increasingly diverse landscape? The first thing we must do is to approach all people with grace. Peter gets at that in what we read a few moments ago: “do this with gentleness and respect.” A friend of mine is Jewish; he grew up in California as a practicing Jew and never really thought much about it until he was in college. There, he encountered a group of Christians who didn’t condemn him, who didn’t shout at him, but who, instead, loved him and showed him grace and kindness. They were friends with him, regardless of their differing faiths. It was that grace that caused him to begin to wonder what was different about these Christians. What made them the way they were? And, as he explored and asked questions, he eventually was drawn to Jesus. As an extra added bonus, one of those Christians who had befriended him ended up marrying him! The question is this: if we are saved by grace, if Jesus came “full of grace and truth” (John 1:14), why do Christians so often show so little grace toward those who believe in different ways? We’re not even good at showing grace toward fellow Christians, and when it comes to those who believe in Islam or Hinduism or whatever it is, we’re far too quick to condemn. Yes, truth is important. It’s vitally important. But that’s only half of the way Jesus came. He came full of truth AND grace. Rather than condemn someone from another faith tradition, we’re called to show mercy, to offer grace, to treat them just as we would want them to treat us (cf. Matthew 7:12). Jesus himself said, “Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you” (Matthew 7:1-2). Take a look at this.
VIDEO: “Invite”
The second thing Christians can do to fight against the myth of being “insensitive” is to live faithfully what we say we believe. Peter and John find themselves in a place to speak about Jesus because they were simply living what they believed. They were on their way to the place of prayer when they came across a beggar who was lame. The man wanted money, and Peter told him he didn’t have any, but he would give him what he had. “In the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, walk,” Peter said (Acts 3:6). When Peter was asked about what had happened, he took the opportunity to share his faith in Jesus, but he didn’t set out to try to preach. He simply offered what he had. He shared his experience with Jesus with someone in need. He lived out his faith. And when he was put on trial, isn’t it interesting that after Peter speaks, the religious leaders “took note that these men had been with Jesus” (4:13)? That’s what made the difference. As Peter lived out his faith, others noticed that it was because of Jesus’ presence and influence in his life.
You know, the biggest challenge to us as Christians is perhaps the accusation that we don’t live what we say we believe. There is a quote that is often attributed to Ghandi that is usually repeated as something like this: “I like your Christ, but I don’t like your Christians.” But the statement actually came from one of Ghandi’s early supporters, as reported by a Methodist missionary in India, Dr. E. Stanley Jones. The speaker’s name was Bara Dada, and what he said was this: “Jesus is ideal and wonderful, but you Christians—you are not like him” (Jones, The Christ of the Indian Road, pg. 114). All too often, his observation is correct. We don’t live the way Jesus called us to. The truth Jesus stood for on that day in his trial before Pilate had to do with loving God and loving others. It had to do with refusing to take revenge on someone who hurts us. It had to do with giving to those in need, caring for those who are the least, the last, and the lost. It had to do with keeping our word, storing up treasures in heaven rather than on earth, and being true to the vows we make. All of that is in an early sermon he preached, by the way, what we call “The Sermon on the Mount” (cf. Matthew 5-7). And we know, when we live that way, people are attracted to that kind of life even before we say a word. That was the experience of the early church, and the church throughout history. When we’re interacting with people of other faiths, we have to be faithful in living what we believe.
Because they will be. I saw this clearly in the Cairo airport at 3:00 in the morning. We got to the airport plenty early, checked our bags and found one open shop which gladly sold us mediocre hot chocolate and day-old muffins. Then we went to find our gate, and as we sat there, half-awake, 3:15 a.m. arrived. Our guide had told us earlier in the week that the time for the first Muslim call to prayer is 3:15 a.m. And, sure enough, a man took a position near us, faced Mecca, and began to sing the call to prayer. Many other men joined him in the time of prayer, and eventually there was a fairly large group, unaware or uncaring of all those around them. And I couldn't help but think about how as Christians tend to hide much more than that. Would we issue a public call to prayer in such a place? Or would we hide quietly and hope no one notices us? We even try to hurry a prayer over a meal at a restaurant, hoping no one notices, right? For Muslims, that time of prayer is a big thing. For us, maybe that’s not a huge issue, but it does beg the question of whether or not we are willing to be consistent and faithful in living out what we say we believe. Muslims also give 2½% of their income to the needy; that’s more than the average United Methodist gives to their local church, let alone to causes beyond the church (cf. Hamilton, When Christians Get It Wrong, pg. 43). Again, do we live our faith? Do our actions back up our belief? Our actions will speak volumes to folks who believe in different ways.
Thirdly, we look for commonalities because we believe all truth is God’s truth. If it’s true, it’s of Jesus. He said so himself when he stood there in front of Pilate: “The reason I was born and came into the world is to testify to the truth” (18:37). We don’t have to fear conversations with people of other faiths. Rather, we can welcome them as we seek areas of commonality, areas where we can share and even work together. Pastor Bill Hybels tells of a man he met one time who had grown up as an African-American Muslim in the southern United States, which put him in less than a majority! Being a professional, he often found himself at cocktail parties and social gatherings, but he was rarely included and so he would make an appearance and then plot his exit. One evening, however, he was in such a setting, standing by himself and looking for a graceful way out when another man, who had been engaged in a discussion with others across the room, broke away from his discussion circle, walked clear across the room, stuck out his hand and introduced himself. They began a conversation, which eventually ended up with the man revealing he was a Muslim. The other man said he was a Christian, but that he knew next to nothing about Islam. Could they get together over coffee so the first man could teach his new friend about Islam? So they did. They began to meet almost weekly, and the Christian was really engaged in asking questions and trying to understand the Muslim way of life. After a few weeks of this, the Muslim man asked his Christian friend to share about his faith, and as they conversed, a great hunger grew in the Muslim man’s heart, to the point where one day, he knelt beside his bed and gave his life to Jesus (cf. Just Walk Across the Room, chapter 1). All because one man took a risk, walked across a room, shared grace, and looked for commonalities in their lives. All truth is God’s truth, and conversations begin best when we have genuine interest in the other and seek to stand on common ground first.
Of course, to find common ground, we need to know a bit about those who have other faiths. What do you know about Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, or any other world religion? It is worth our time, and might even spur on our own faith, to spend some time learning about those who are our neighbors. There are a couple of books listed on the Sermon Study Guide today that would be good starting points. You can always do research on the internet, though don’t believe everything you read there! Are you willing to learn so that you might find common ground as a starting point for spiritual conversations?
Now, this is not to say that all religions are equal. As Christians, we do believe that Jesus is the only way we know to find salvation. Beyond that, we believe that Jesus is God, and other faiths do not share that belief, so it impossible for Jesus to be God and at the same time not be God. As Jeffrey Burton Russell puts it, “The only way that all religions can be equal is if they are all meaningless” (Exposing Myths About Christianity, pg. 71). At the same time, we hang onto the deep, deep love God has for his creation, for all of his creation. A hymn puts it this way:
Your love, O God, is broad like beach and meadow
Wide as the wind, and our eternal home
You leave us free to seek you or reject you
You give us room to answer “yes” or “no” (UMH 120).
Perhaps we would do well to take a cue from Billy Graham, who was asked a few years ago what he thought about other religions. Graham has preached his entire life about finding in salvation in Jesus, and he is ever more sure and certain of his faith in Jesus as he nears the end of his life. But when he was asked about how God will handle other faiths, Graham responds, “Those are decisions only the Lord will make…I don’t want to speculate about all that. I believe the love of God is absolute. He said he gave his son for the whole world, and I think he loves everybody regardless of what label they have” (qtd. in Hamilton, Seeing Gray in a World of Black and White, pg. 111).
“What is truth?” The words echoed throughout that Antonia Fortress, even as Pilate walked away. What would you say to this Roman governor? Would you respond with grace? Would you live out your faith? Would you be able to look for commonalities as you share your belief in Jesus as the truth? Our call is to reach out, like the disciples did with the lame beggar. Seek to meet a need and offer what you have. Love them in Jesus’ name and for his sake, for Christians are not called to be insensitive toward those who don’t share our faith. Rather, we’re called to love God, love others and offer Jesus. That is our priority. That is our calling. So our prayer this morning is this: O God, show me how to love.